November 18, 2026

Piesanos Brings the Story of Pepperoni to Peppfest

1.8 min read| Published On: November 18th, 2026|

By Gina Horan

Piesanos Brings the Story of Pepperoni to Peppfest

1.8 min read| Published On: November 18th, 2026|

Pepperoni is practically synonymous with pizza in America, and for Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, it’s been a defining ingredient since the beginning.

But the ingredient itself has almost nothing to do with Italy, despite the name. In Italy, a “pepperoni pizza” means a pizza topped with peppers, not meat. Pepperoni comes from peperone, the Italian word for bell pepper.

The Gainesville-based chain has built much of its identity around pepperoni from its earliest days, and PeppFest, its latest ode to the topping, takes that devotion further than usual. The limited-time menu event, running through December, centers on four distinct styles of pepperoni: mini cup and char, classic sliced, diced and spicy Napoletana.

“Our variety is what sets us apart,” says David Hew, Piesanos’ director of marketing. “Between the different pepperoni styles and more than 20 other items on our menu, we wanted everyone to know what we’re able to offer.”

Business has been growing. Piesanos recently opened a new location in Middleton, adding to locations already established in Ocala, The Villages and across its Gainesville home base. The company, founded 17 years ago by Joel Mills and Mike Akey, built PeppFest around five new menu additions: a Quadruple Pepperoni Pizza featuring all four pepperoni styles, a golden-baked Pepperoni Pocket, a Pepperoni Quesadilla, a Tortellini Pepperoni Salad and Pepperoni Cheesy Bread.

The devotion even extends to the bar, where a Hot Honey Pepperoni Margarita puts the topping somewhere pepperoni rarely goes.

Pepperoni Quesadilla

The spicy red slices Americans know were actually invented in New York City, first recorded in Italian delis around 1919. Italian immigrant butchers, unable to source the same ingredients they’d used back home, improvised with paprika and chili spices instead, building something new out of what was actually available rather than what they remembered.

Many of the people who now call Lake and Sumter home grew up eating it in those same neighborhoods, before New York, New Jersey and Connecticut sent so many of their own south to Florida.

HotHoney Pepperoni Margarita

For decades, pepperoni stayed a deli meat, sliced for sandwiches rather than pizza. It didn’t become a pizza topping until the 1950s, once pizza itself took off across the country. These days, it’s the most popular pizza topping in America after cheese itself, a reliable favorite for kids and adults alike.

A century after Italian immigrants built something new out of spare ingredients in a New York deli, that same instinct for reinvention is still playing out on pizzas across Lake and Sumter counties.

Photos Provided

Leave A Comment

About the Author: Gina Horan

Gina moved to Central Florida from the San Francisco Bay Area in 2021. She holds a degree in linguistics and has worked as a fashion editor, photo stylist, lifestyle columnist and food writer since 1995. She later covered travel, events, restaurants, music festivals and sports throughout Northern California, including work as a morning show host with KSAN radio and food critic for KRON Bay TV. A veteran bartender, she has worked in hospitality on and off since high school. Gina joined Akers Media in 2022 and is currently the Food and Lifestyle Editor. Her passions include travel, road trips, history books and podcasts, tasting menus and arriving in a new city without a map.

Share This Story!

Never miss an issue,  Sign-Up for the Style Newsletter!