November 18, 2026

The Shoe Still Fits as Becker’s Best Begins 12th Year

3.3 min read| Published On: November 18th, 2026|

By Gina Horan

The Shoe Still Fits as Becker’s Best Begins 12th Year

3.3 min read| Published On: November 18th, 2026|

Amy Becker doesn’t mind how many shoe boxes come off the shelf. If it takes a dozen pairs to find the right fit, that’s a dozen opportunities to figure out what works.

“What might be a 14-hour shoe for me could be a five-minute shoe for someone else,” Amy says. “Try on as many pairs as you want until you find the right ones.”

That patience has helped Becker’s Best Shoes build a following in downtown Mount Dora, where regulars help sustain the business through slower summers and shape what Amy brings into the store. Having celebrated its 11th anniversary, the shop is beginning its 12th year, which is how Amy prefers to count.

“I like to gauge it on the year we are starting,” Amy says.

Her route to the store began with a prayer and a shoe brand that came to mind in the middle of the night.

Retail runs through three generations of Amy’s family in Mississippi. She spent years in the business before returning to school for a master’s degree and working in special education for a decade. Eventually, concerns about whether she could retire from that career prompted her to consider what might come next.

The name she heard that night was Alegria, a brand she had discovered while teaching.

Researching opportunities with the company led her to Mount Dora. The downtown reminded her of the place she grew up, and when she visited a shoe store there, a small sign caught her attention.

The store was for sale.

Within 45 days, Amy and Fred Price owned it, backed by financial and moral support from family. Two years later, an SBA loan allowed them to repay the people who helped them get started.

“I thought it was my destiny,” Amy says.

The name Becker’s Best came from her classroom, where she recognized students for individual improvement. Success looked different for each child, and the awards gave them a chance to celebrate their own progress.

That experience still influences how she works with customers.

“Feet are like special needs kids,” Amy says. “Each is unique and requires individual attention.”

She also acknowledges that each person brings a different combination of foot shape, weight, back problems and daily demands. Finding what works requires the individual attention she gave her students.

A measurement provides a starting point, but Amy herself can tell just by looking at the shoe where to begin the search.

“I can wear four different sizes in the store, depending on the brand,” Amy says.

Sometimes, finding the right pair brings a reaction that goes well beyond liking how a shoe looks.

“I remember one customer,” Amy says. “She was so frustrated with the selections at the stores and even online. She started to tear up and told me it was the first time she could walk properly without pain.”

Amy also makes a point of carrying attractive shoes in larger women’s sizes, giving shoppers options they can feel good about wearing.

The store carries merchandise from more than 60 vendors, with footwear brands including Hoka, Brooks, On, Birkenstock, OluKai, Alegria and Rieker. Athletic shoes share space with sandals, casual styles and colorful designs that give customers choices beyond a basic walking shoe.

Buying trips to Atlanta help Amy keep that selection evolving. She wears a sample size, allowing her to try many shoes herself, but her own favorites don’t automatically earn shelf space.

“I have to buy for my customer,” Amy says.

Knowing those customers helps her choose socks, bags, belts and gifts, too. Familiar faces give her someone to picture when she considers a new style, color or brand. The assortment reflects the people who shop there and what they return to find.

Staff members don’t work on commission. The time spent trying another size or pulling another box is part of the service, an approach recognized through repeated national Gold Medal Service Awards from Footwear Insight and a 2026 Best of Florida regional award in Clothing & Shoe Stores.

That same instinct for meeting people exactly where they are led Amy and Fred to open Bodystreet Mount Dora a year ago. It isn’t really a second business, Amy says, so much as another way of paying attention to a body that’s asking for help.

For nearly 12 years, that attention has started at the feet.

“You wouldn’t think that shoes and feet could change people’s lives,” Amy says. “But I’ve seen it, and they do.”

Becker’s Best Shoes / 404 N Donnelly St., Mount Dora / 352.385.0909 / beckersbestshoes.com

Photos: Gina Horan

Leave A Comment

About the Author: Gina Horan

Gina moved to Central Florida from the San Francisco Bay Area in 2021. She holds a degree in linguistics and has worked as a fashion editor, photo stylist, lifestyle columnist and food writer since 1995. She later covered travel, events, restaurants, music festivals and sports throughout Northern California, including work as a morning show host with KSAN radio and food critic for KRON Bay TV. A veteran bartender, she has worked in hospitality on and off since high school. Gina joined Akers Media in 2022 and is currently the Food and Lifestyle Editor. Her passions include travel, road trips, history books and podcasts, tasting menus and arriving in a new city without a map.

Share This Story!

Never miss an issue,  Sign-Up for the Style Newsletter!