Delicious homemade ice cream in a variety of flavors draws all ages to Mystic Ice Cream. Owners Darrell and Lisa Day both have their favorites. Darrell enjoys the peanut butter crunch, a creamy, light peanut butter ice cream with Reese’s crumbles and Reese’s Pieces, while Lisa, loves the butterscotch crunch, a vanilla-based ice cream with butterscotch schnapps and Heath candy bar crumbles. The Days also serve adult ice creams with liqueur, including the popular Mystic Slide featuring chocolate ice cream with Kahlúa and amaretto. Mystic Ice Cream seats 80 people and the parlor is a pop culture museum filled with Beatles memorabilia. This is also a fun place to go for nightly entertainment, including game shows, trivia night and karaoke.

Tuesday-Sunday 1pm-9pm

Mystic Ice Cream

1217 W. Miller St. (County Road 466A), Fruitland Park
352.812.1366 | mysticicecream.com